Friday, August 8, 2014

New Date for Judge's Panel


The Judge's Panel on Mistakes Attorneys Make in Juvenile Court has been postponed until

Friday, September 19, 2014

Please mark you calendars with the change.  The other details will remain the same.  Several of our Juvenile Court Judges, including Judge James R. Michie Jr. and Judge Sharon S. Sipes, will discuss how to improve juvenile court practice including the mistakes that attorneys make in court.

When:     12:00-1:30pm 
What:     Lunch with panel discussion following
Where:   Sheraton Salt Lake City
Cost:       FREE!

For those unable to attend in person we are still planing on broadcasting the event over the web at 12:30pm.  One hour of CLE will be requested from the Bar.  Registration is now open!




Thursday, August 7, 2014

Law Review Article on Legal Guardianship under ASFA


Sara Katz, a former parental defender and now Professor of Law at Temple University has published an article in Michigan Law Review on the topic of Legal Guardianships and the Adoption and Safe Families Act.  Her introduction states:
This Article argues that it does not serve the interest of children or parents to prevent parents entirely from filing for custody after legal guardianship is granted. To the extent a parent's rights are not terminated as a result of her child-welfare involvement, a family's contact with the child-welfare system should not lessen the value the law places on the parent-child relationship. In short, the courthouse doors should not be closed to children and their parents by barring parents from later requesting, in appropriate circumstances, that a court determine whether it is in that child's best interests to return to the parent. Although permanency has value in the child-welfare context, permanency unto itself should not be the goal in resolving custody disputes--determining children's best interests should always be at the forefront in all custody cases, whether between private parties or between the parent and the state. This Article posits that parents should retain the right to file to vacate the guardianship and regain primary custody, but makes recommendations to the states so as to ensure children have the stability they need while promoting their best interests.
You can download a copy HERE.

Tuesday, August 5, 2014

Spotlight: J. Robert Latham

Although my law practice sometimes takes me throughout Utah, my home and office are located in St. George. Thus, most of my practice occurs in southern Utah. I am one of four attorneys who contract with Washington County to represent indigent parties in the two juvenile courts.
What I love about parental defense work is making a positive difference. It’s evident in the vast majority of cases in which I have participated that my advocacy and counsel yielded a better outcome for the parent than had the parent appeared without an attorney. The taxpayer benefits from resisted and reduced state interventions as well.
In a recent matter, I was directed by the court to appear at an expedited shelter hearing. (I had anticipated a quick hearing that early afternoon, so I delayed having lunch.) Three-and-a-half hours after my appointment to represent the parent, the judge ordered that the newborn child be returned to the parent’s custody, over the objection of both the AAG and GAL. The scenario reminded me of this stanza from a Paul Simon tune:

No, I would not give you false hope
On this strange and mournful day
But the mother and child reunion
Is only a motion away


Practice tip/trick: The Utah Administrative Office of the Courts makes XChange available to parental defenders for searches performed in connection with contracted duties at no charge. Although C.A.R.E. is helpful, XChange hosts probable cause statements and other useful pleadings that can shed light on a client’s or related party’s companion matter(s). Greenfiling also offers a reduced rate to parental defenders for its unlimited e-filing service.

Monday, August 4, 2014

Vegas Conference Attendees Announced!


The PDA is pleased to announce the attorneys who have been selected to attend the National Child Abuse Defense and Resource Center Conference in Las Vegas on October 16-18, 2014.  

Angela Fonnesbeck

Carol Mortensen

J. Robert Latham

Congratulations!  Please contact Kate for details on how to register.

Monday, July 28, 2014

NCJFCJ Conference


From Kate Hansen, PDA Director:

On July 14-16, 2014,  I attended the annual conference for the National Council for Juvenile and Family Court Judges.  It was an interesting conference that addressed a variety of issues.  You can see the reported highlights HERE.  There are two big take aways I got from the conference with regard to child welfare.

1. There was quite a lot of talk about evidence based interventions.  In the context of child welfare this would mean making sure that the services that parents are required to do have studies and other evidence to back up why they are helpful, useful and what they accomplish.  It makes no sense to ask a parent to do something that is not actually going to benefit them or help them get their kids back.  For example this would be true of parenting classes.  If the class does not actually help the parent become better at parenting then there is no reason for them to take it.  Generic counseling is unlikely to be helpful if it is not targeted to resolving issues that caused the parent to become involved with DCFS in the first place.

2. Trauma informed care.  There is a movement to view child offenders and children involved with DCFS as having experienced some trauma and treating the trauma rather than just changing the behavior or removing them from the harmful situation.  It seems to me that parents could be viewed the same way.  I would think it highly likely that large number of parents have had some sort of their own trauma that is contributing to their involvement with DCFS.  The hoops the courts ask parents to jump through should not be just hoops and punishments. If viewed through a trauma lens, the services required of parents should be focused on helping them learn to overcome whatever traumas they have experienced and helping them to be the parents they have a right to be.

Is DCFS making reasonable efforts to prevent removal and to reunify, if parents are asked to participate in services that are not evidence based or not trauma informed?

Child Welfare In the News


The New York Times recently featured a Op-Ed piece on criminalizing parenting that is well worth the read.  You can find it HERE.  Yesterday there was a letter to the editor in response that underlines the importance of parent representation.  You can find that HERE.

HERE is an article about a mother who lost her kids because she needed housing.

HERE is an article about the right to parent even if you are poor.

HERE is a great story about a new mother with bi-polar disorder who was found capable of parenting.

Wednesday, July 23, 2014

Where to report complaints about DCFS



According to the Child Welfare Ombudsman Annual Report: 

In January 1996, the Executive Director of the Department of Human Services created the Utah Office of Child Protection Ombudsman, independent from Child and Family Services, where the public could report concerns about cases under Child and Family Services' jurisdiction.  In 1998, the Utah Legislature codified the role and authority of the Ombudsman's Office by enacting Section 62A-4a-209 of Utah Code, which states:
"...the ombudsman shall, upon receipt of a complain from any person, investigate whether an act or omission of the division with respect to a particular child: (i) is contrary to statute, rule, or policy; (ii) places a child's health or safety at risk; (iii) is made without an adequate statement of reason; or (iv) is based on irrelevant, immaterial, or erroneous grounds..."
The purpose of the Ombudsman's Office is to receive and investigate complaints, provide a voice to the consumer/complainant, promote a way whereby concerns or disputes are addressed at the lowest level possible, and ensure that Child and Family Services is providing adequate services to their clients.  Currently, the Ombudsman's Office is the only independent office in State government where complainants can express their concerns about child welfare cases.  For this reason the Ombudsman's Office is a unique resource to Utah's citizens.

The website for the Ombudsman is: http://ocpo.utah.gov/