Friday, December 5, 2014

FREE Webinars Focusing on Immigration Issues


The National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges is hosting a two-part webinar series exploring the complexities that arise when working with immigrant families.  The webinars are designed as a conversation and learning opportunity for child welfare personnel, legal professionals, advocates, and other community members working with immigrant populations.

Special Immigrant Juvenile (SIJ) Status -- What Judicial Officers and Court Stakeholders Need to Know
Presented by Casey Family Programs, the Immigrant Legal Resource Center (ILRC) and the NCJFCJ
Date: Monday, December 15, 2014
Time: 9am to 10am PST / Noon to 1pm EST
Cost: FREE
Register HERE
Eileen Matuszak of USCIS will give a brief description of SIJ status and respond to SIJ questions frequently asked by the courts. This presentation will provide an opportunity for judges to ask general SIJ questions of the federal agency responsible for administering the SIJ program. Additionally, Angie Junck of the ILRC will present information on newly enacted state laws addressing SIJ issues. Lastly, Elizabeth Thornton of Casey Family Programs will describe strategies and tools used to raise awareness of the SIJ program with state child welfare agencies and juvenile court judges. 

Immigrant Families -- How to Best Serve Them 
Presented by Casey Family Program, the American Bar Association Center on Children and the Law and the NCJFCJ
Date: Thursday, December 18, 2014
Time: Noon to 1pm PST / 3pm to 4pm EST
Cost: FREE
Register HERE
Andrew Lorenzen-Strait of ICE will explain the Facilitating Parental Interests in the Course of Civil Immigration Enforcement Activities Directive  (also known as the Parental Interest Directive). Mr. Lorenzen-Strait will describe how ICE’s Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) field offices handle family court cases, as well as how courts can collaborate with ICE to help facilitate participation by parents in child welfare cases. Additionally, Kevonne Small of DOJ will discuss Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and its application to dependency courts and child welfare agencies, and will discuss how court and child welfare agency responses to immigrant parents may implicate this law. Lastly, Cristina Cooper of the ABA will describe steps states can take to mitigate some of the barriers faced by immigrant families involved in the child welfare system, as well as discuss what falls under the purview of the current federal and state laws. 

Monday, November 24, 2014

Boot Camp for Parental Defenders is now LIVE! Plus a Discount Code


New Online CLE!  You can now view the training Juvenile Court Boot Camp for Parental Defenders.
In this video Grant Dickinson of the PDA covers the basics of a parental defense case from shelter hearing to termination with lots of tips and tricks along the way.  If you are new to parental defense or just want to brush up on the basics this video is for you.
  • Click HERE to view the program
  • 1 hour of self-study CLE available
  • $15.00 
  • Use the discount code BOOTCAMP to view it for FREE until December 31, 2014

Not Everyone Has A Right To Counsel When Their Parental Rights Are Terminated


The National Coalition for a Civil Right to Counsel (NCCRC) is a coalition organized by the Public Justice Center that encourages, supports and coordinates advocacy to expand recognition and implementation of a right to counsel in civil cases--including dependency and termination of parental rights proceedings.

Most states provide a right to counsel in a dependency case or when parental rights are being terminated, but in some cases it is left to the judge's discretion or the right is qualified.  To see how the states stack up click HERE or on the map.

Friday, November 21, 2014

Motion and Memorandum to Vacate Appointments


One of the questions the Parental Defense Alliance is most frequently asked is, “under what circumstances can a party be appointed counsel?”

The statute that governs the appointment of counsel in child welfare cases is U.C.A. § 78A-6-1111

Simply it states that in order to be entitled to counsel, the case must be a state initiated Petition in which the party is indigent.  Indigent means that the party makes less than 150% of the U.S. poverty guidelines (See http://aspe.hhs.gov/poverty/14computations.cfm), or lacks the income, assets, and credit to obtain or finance counsel.

This conflicts with Utah Rule of Juvenile Procedure 37(d) which states that “Counsel may be appointed by the court for an indigent respondent who is a parent, guardian or custodian of the child…”  Counties are entitled to notice of all appointments and the county is entitled to a hearing.

We have recently added to our Forms bank a Motion and Memorandum to Vacate Appointments.  http://www.parentaldefense.org/Forms-Library

Being diligent in reviewing the applications for appointment of counsel will allow public defenders to serve that portion of the population that truly qualify for the assistance to decrease the strain on our public defenders.

If you feel as if an application for appointed counsel was inappropriately granted speak with your contract administrator or County Clerk to determine if they would like challenge the appointment.  As a note, it is the County that has the right to challenge the appointment, not the individual attorney and as such you must have your county’s authorization to represent them, or they must have their county attorney’s office challenge the matter.

Wednesday, November 19, 2014

Resources for Parents With Trauma Histories


The National Child Traumatic Stress Network has fantastic resources for children who experience trauma and recognizes that parents involved in the child welfare system have also likely experienced their own trauma.  Check out their webpage dedicated to Birth Parents with Trauma Histories and the Child Welfare System.

The following is an introduction to one of their pamphlets, Birth parents with trauma histories and the child welfare system: A guide for judges and attorneys (link available below):
Judges and attorneys who work in the child welfare system are well aware that many of the children in the system have experienced trauma; less well recognized is that the birth parents of these children often have their own histories of childhood and adult trauma. For example, research indicates that 30-60% of maltreated children have caretakers who have experienced domestic violence themselves. Past or present experiences of trauma can affect a parent’s confidence and ability to keep children safe, work effectively with child welfare staff, and respond to the requirements of the courts. Fortunately, trauma-informed services are increasingly available for both parents and children who need them. Trauma-informed services include mental health services offered by trained professionals that address specific reactions to traumatic events. By recognizing the potential impact of trauma on parenting, judges and attorneys can more easily connect parents with those services.   
If you are looking for additional resources for parents who experience trauma.  Below are some of the pamphlets available:

For Parents
For Child Welfare Staff
For Judges and Attorneys
For Mental Health Professionals
For Resource Parents
For Court-Based Child Advocates and Guardian ad Litem

Monday, November 17, 2014

Would You Like to Become Certified in Child Welfare Law?


As some of you may be aware the National Association of Counsel for Children offers a certification in Child Welfare law.  You can find more information about the certification HERE.

The Parental Defense Alliance is interested in bringing the NACC out to Utah to conduct a full day exam preparation training at little or no cost to our members.  This is an expensive training.  In addition, those interested must meet certain criteria, and pay $300 to apply, plus $350 to sit for the test.  The PDA is also interested in helping to defray the cost of these fees. 

Due to the large financial commitment, we would like to get a head count of those who are interested in becoming certified and participating in the training, which would most likely take place the Wednesday before the annual conference on April 22, 2015.

In order to sit for the exam you must meet the following criteria:
  • 3 or more year practicing law
  • 30% or more of the last three years involved in child welfare law
  • 36 hours of CLE within the last three years in courses relevant to child welfare law
  • A writing sample drafted within the last three years that demonstrates legal analysis of child welfare law.  This can be a pleading.
If you can meet these criteria and are interested in the exam preparation training, please email me at kate@parentaldefense.org by November 30, 2014.

Angela Fonnesbeck's Report on the NCADRC Conference

During my recent attendance at the National Child Abuse Defense and Resource Center’s 17th Annual International Conference I was reminded of the ethical considerations and concerns that must be confronted in all matters involving abuse.

Each morning of the conference opened with a presentation on ethics, highlighting the importance of our ethical responsibilities to clients as we later sort through the facts and laws of the case at hand.

Throughout these presentations three areas in particular stood out as deserving of our attention,

  1. The fully informed client:  A client is entitled to full disclosure from their attorney – whether appointed or privately hired.  This is our duty as lawyers.  The client has the right to know all the positive aspects of their case, as well as the pitfalls of their case.  The client has a right to know what happens next and the potential consequences of all legal options.  Utah Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.4, requires that a lawyer, among other things, promptly inform the client of any decision or circumstance requiring their informed consent, keep the client informed about the status of the matter and promptly comply with requests for information.  Most of the presenters at this conference believe that a fully informed client had the right to know whether the attorney representing them will have any moral objections to the issues.  For example, if your client has been convicted of viewing child pornography will you be able to professionally represent them regardless of a personal bias? Utah Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 6.2, dealing with the acceptance of appointments, specifically indicates that a lawyer should not avoid appointment unless the “client or the cause is so repugnant to the lawyer as to be likely to impair the client-lawyer relationship.                                                                                                               
  2. Who can/should be present during attorney-client meetings:  If anyone is present during any meeting with your client, confidentiality is waived.   This is especially important when representing children whose parents are paying the legal fees.  While parents may want to sit in on meetings with the client, to allow them to do so would waive confidentiality and should be avoided.  The presenters believed that these exclusions from attorney-client meetings were critical, as the person paying the fee often believes they have control over the case – which they do not.   Also, the presenters believed an attorney was less likely to get the “whole truth” out of a client, especially a minor, if the parents were present.                                                       
  3. It is our responsible conduct complete discovery:  As the legal expert in a case our clients are relying on us to fully and completely engage in discovery. This includes: (i) understanding all of the facts, including the facts from our client’s perspective and how we may prove those facts to be true; (ii) subpoenaing all medical records (labs, consults, follow-up visits), reading them to determine what is there and what is missing, and understanding them; and (iii) hiring experts.

Even if as attorneys we believe we fully understand our ethical responsibilities to our clients, these presenters served as a reminder that it should be a focus of our practice and representation.   It is a duty we owe our clients who put their faith and trust in us as legal professionals.