Monday, January 12, 2015
Book Review: Handbook on Questioning Children
Handbook on Questioning Children
By Anne Graffam Walker, Ph.D.
The Parental Defense Alliance has added to its library a new book, The Handbook on Questioning Children: A Linguistic Perspective (3rd Edition). This book is a must-read for anyone who working in child welfare. There are common misperceptions about how to interview a child. This book will assist defense attorneys with identifying problems in the interviews conducted and can assist with the daunting task of examining a child in open court. Above all, it can be used to give guidance in the construction of your questions.
The book focuses mainly on studies conducted with children 10 years of age and younger, but includes tidbits regarding older children’s understanding and use of language. The Appendix contains a Checklist for Interviewing Children that is a perfect refresher and a good guide for refining your questions prior to trial or interviewing children.
Trial Tip: How to use in cross examination of case worker.
Q: You have received training in the interviewing of children.
A: Yes.
Q: One of the principles important in eliciting truth from children is to avoid being suggestive in your questions.
A: Yes.
Q: You are trained to avoid the use of phrases like, “I believe you told me,” in attempting to trigger a response in a child.
A: Yes.
Q: Your training also told you that starting a question in this manner may result in an unreliable response.
A: Yes.
Q: Yet in your interview of the child regarding the abuse, you used the following question “Johnny, I believe you told me about when you daddy mistreated you.”
A: Yes.
Q: [So by your own testimony, the response to your question may be unreliable because of the manner in which you asked the question]
This final question should be used with care. It is less risky to simply remind the Court of your cross examination and draw the same conclusion without the risk of eliciting an explanation from the worker.
It would be helpful for all parental-defense attorneys to be familiar with child interview techniques and critical statements that can elicit unreliable responses from children. Parental Defense Attorneys should be able to review a child interview and identify problems with the interview that call into question the reliability of the answers. This book will help you to develop a working knowledge of the guiding principles in interviewing children and missteps that may have been taken in the interviews conducted with the children of your clients.
You can purchase copies HERE.
Tuesday, January 6, 2015
Department of Justice Seeks ICWA Compliance
Recently, Sheldon Spotted Elk, legal counsel for the Ute Tribe, attended the Tribal Nations meeting in Washington, DC. With Mr. Spotted Elk's permission we are posting his comments, and encourage all to follow the link provided to read the full text of Eric Holder’s address.
Greetings,
Yesterday during the Tribal Nations meeting in Washington DC, Eric Holder, Attorney General announced that DOJ is going to begin to actively file against ICWA violations. This is exciting and fulfillment of the trust responsibility. I feel that some of the work we have done is solid!!!!! And has been recognized at National Conferences that I have been in attendance. Proud to work with all of you and with Misty Butler, she is going to be missed.
“Today, I am pleased to announce that the Department of Justice is launching a new initiative to promote compliance with the Indian Child Welfare Act. Under this important effort, we are working to actively identify state-court cases where the United States can file briefs opposing the unnecessary and illegal removal of Indian children from their families and their tribal communities. We are partnering with the Departments of the Interior and Health and Human Services to make sure that all the tools available to the federal government are used to promote compliance with this important law. And we will join with those departments, and with tribes and Indian child-welfare organizations across the country, to explore training for state judges and agencies; to promote tribes’ authority to make placement decisions affecting tribal children; to gather information about where the Indian Child Welfare Act is being systematically violated; and to take appropriate, targeted action to ensure that the next generation of great tribal leaders can grow up in homes that are not only safe and loving, but also suffused with the proud traditions of Indian cultures”.
FULL TEXT of Holder’s Speech:
http://www.justice.gov/opa/speech/attorney-general-eric-holder-delivers-remarks-during-white-house-tribal-nations
Cheers,
Sheldon
Monday, January 5, 2015
Can Parental Defense Attorneys Communicate with DCFS Caseworkers?
At our Judge’s Panel Luncheon, a question came up regarding whether a parent attorney could attend a child and family team meeting or otherwise communicate with a DCFS caseworker without the presence of an AAG. The following advisory opinion offers the answer.
Utah Rules of Judicial Administration Chapter 13 Rule 4.2 prohibits contact of represented persons by attorneys unless authorized by law, rule, or court order.
In 1993, the advisory committee was asked in regards to the application of this rule in the context of agency employees and the Attorney General’s office.
The office provided the following opinion:
A lawyer representing a government department may not prevent his non-government counterpart from contacting any employee of the government office or department outside his/her presence, whether or not the communication involves a matter in litigation. However, if counsel for a private party contacts a government employee about pending litigation, counsel must inform the government employee (a) about the pending litigation or that the matter has been referred to agency counsel and (b) about his representation of a private party in that litigation.
Utah Ethics Adv. Op. No. 115 (1993).
This opinion was reaffirmed in July 1994 by Utah Ethic Adv.Op.No. 115R (1994).
In short, yes, a parental defense attorney can speak with the caseworker regarding the case--and even attend a family group meeting--without the AAG being present and without the AAG's permission, if the attorney discloses to the worker the existence of the litigation and discloses who the attorney represents.
Thursday, January 1, 2015
Get Ready for Electronic Records
Some of you may be aware that Utah's Juvenile Court system is moving toward electronic records. The PDA recently attended a an information session held by the AOC Juvenile Court Team regarding the new e-filing process.
You will see from the infographic above that the first phase of the roll out will be mandatory by October 2015. This will mean that for cases that have already been assigned a number by the clerk's office you will be required to file all pleadings and motions electronically. The second phase will follow and will be for the creation of new cases.
One of the differences between e-filing at the District Court and e-filing at the Juvenile Court is that all filings for the Juvenile Court will be through CARE. CARE stands for the Court and Agencies Record Exchange and is a portal not only for filing and accessing electronic records but contain information on specific cases and court calendars.
For those of you unfamiliar with CARE, now is the time to request access and familiarize yourself with the system. You do not need to have any cases pending in the Juvenile Court in order to obtain a login. We encourage all parental defense attorneys to request access to CARE.
Below are some helpful links to get your started:
If you have any questions please let us know.
Friday, December 26, 2014
Registration for our Parent Time Lunches in February is now OPEN!
We will be holding three CLE luncheons in February around the state and discussing how to use Parent Time Timelines. We hope you can join us! You will get a fantastic lunch full of relevant information for only $5. Invite your friends. One hour of CLE credit pending.
Note: Make sure you click on the correct link for the city and date you want.
St. George
February 6, 2015
12:00p.m. - 1:30p.m.
Painted Pony, 2 West Saint George Boulevard #22, St. George, UT 84770
Cost: $5.00
REGISTER HERE
Richfield
February 20, 2015
12:00p.m. - 1:30p.m.
Sagebrush Grill, 1345 South 350 West, Richfield, UT 84701
Cost: $5.00
REGISTER HERE
Vernal
February 27, 2015
12:00p.m. - 1:30p.m.
Vernal Quarry, 25 South Vernal Avenue, Vernal, UT 84078
Cost: $5.00
REGISTER HERE
Tuesday, December 9, 2014
Motion for Standard Parent Time and Upcoming CLE Luncheons
One of the most popular posts on this blog has been the summary of a presentation from the CIP Summit on the topic of family/parent time. You can read the original post HERE.
We have added to the Forms Library on our website a Motion for Standard Parent Time which you can download and tailor to you specific cases.
In order to continue a discussion on the topic of Parent Time the PDA will be holding three CLE luncheons in February. We hope you can attend one:
February 6, 2015: St. George, Utah
February 20, 2015: Richfield, Utah
February 27, 2014: Vernal, Utah
Stay tuned for more details.
Monday, December 8, 2014
Vote for Breakfast at the Annual Conference!
I have some good news! The PDA Annual Conference is returning to the Zermatt Resort. We hope you are planning on joining us.
For the first time ever, the PDA is allowing its members to help choose what they eat at the annual conference.
One thing you should be aware of: as of July 1, 2013, the PDA has been required by the State of Utah to use the per diem pricing for state employees. In the past, the PDA was not restricted in the amount it could spend on food at conferences, but now we are put on equal footing with all state employees including AGs, GALs, etc.
The use of per diem pricing limits what we can offer. Below are the options that the Zermatt has available. Vote for your favorite and the top two will be our choices for conference on April 23 and 24, 2015.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






